Asked and Answered

FOR the guy in charge of promoting Yahoo!Since the service was launched a year ago, Yahoo!
Answers, Bradley Horowitz seems awfullyhas introduced 20 localized versions, including one for
preoccupied with questions these days.the Philippines ( These local versions enable visitors to
What, for example, did Hillary Clinton, Oprah Winfrey,post questions to and receive answers from their
Stephen Hawking, and Bono hope to learn from theown online communities.
"wisdom of the crowd?"All told, the service draws 90 million users a year, and
The celebrity questions are part of a clever effort tohas generated about 250 million answers, Yahoo!
drum up interest and participation in Yahoo! Answers,says.
the Internet giant's poster child for "social search."Adding some star attraction to the service, Yahoo!
Yahoo! Answers ( is a free service that enableshas encouraged celebrities to ask their questions
visitors to ask questions on any topic and have themonline, giving ordinary people the chance to interact
answered by other people online. The same onlinewith them.
community gets to vote for the best answers.Presidential candidate Hillary Clinton, for example,
Social search, explains Horowitz, vice president ofasked how ordinary Americans would improve health
product strategy at Yahoo!, is the next phase ofcare in the United States.
Internet search.Oprah asked: "If you were given $1,000 to change
The first phase, pioneered by Yahoo!, focused onthe life of a perfect stranger, what would you do?"
human-edited directories that organized Web pagesStephen Hawking wanted to know how the human
according to content in a hierarchical fashion.race could survive the next 100 years, and U2's Bono
The second, marked by search engines such asasked what we can do to make poverty history.
Altavista, used software to ferret out pages on theIn Malaysia, Yahoo! invited awarded movie director
Web as these became too numerous to catalogYasmin Ahmad to ask her question, and she wanted
manually.to know what could be done to nurture and support
The third phase, marked by the ascendancy ofaspiring Malaysian filmmakers. At last week's launch,
Google, provided more relevant results by combiningYahoo! was still screening choices for a Filipino
search algorithms with an analysis and ranking ofcelebrity.
Web pages based on the number and quality ofThere is no guarantee that celebrities will really listen
other pages that linked to them.to the answers, of course. Clinton, for example,
Social search combines the best properties of thereceived over 38,000 replies in just two days-then
first three phases. In Yahoo! Answers, for example,left it to the community to pick the best answer, a
answers are filtered through a grading system thatmove that many felt was a cop-out.
lets members of the online community rate theRemarked Barry M: "I wonder why anyone actually
quality of answers.thought Hillary would listen to anything we had to
"Search today, while powerful, is inherently limited. Itsay. Have you ever seen any politician ask a question
connects keywords to Web pages. Yahoo! Answersand then 'listen' to the answer? If you expected her
provides real answers to real questions," saysto read your answers and choose a winner, you
Horowitz.should have included a blank check with your initial
To post questions or answer them on Yahoo!response."
Answers, you'll need to log in using a Yahoo! ID. AUndeterred, I logged on and asked my own question:
point system offers incentives for answering"When will Yahoo! finally support Linux on Yahoo!
questions well.Widgets?" Horowitz didn't know, so I figured maybe
A first-time user gets 100 points to start and can usesomeone else would. It's been three days-and I've
these to ask questions. You gain points by logging in,received only one reply. Sadly, it wasn't from anyone
answering questions, choosing the best answer toat Yahoo!--and it wasn't even very useful.
your questions, or by voting for the best answer toTrivial as this example might seem, it highlights one
other questions. Active participation enhances yourserious challenge that Yahoo! needs to address to
online reputation, which is measured by yourmake Answers even more responsive: making sure
accumulated points and level.that the right people see the right questions.