| In the middle of the scheme for regional | | | | economic and political conditions for institutionalising |
| incorporation, the South Asian Association for | | | | regional co-operation were missing. Both India and |
| Regional Co-operation is relatively a new concept | | | | Pakistan accepted the proposal for regional |
| subject to the tremendous reflection of | | | | co-operation only 'in principle'. They could accept a |
| socio-economic conditions of these regions. The | | | | regional forum only when it did not seek to |
| framework for the SAARC programme started on in | | | | undermine their respective interests. Accordingly, it |
| the early 1980 was created by the specific economic | | | | was suggested that unanimity in decisions and |
| and political developments for the preceding years. | | | | avoidance of bilateral and contentious issues should |
| Economically, the failure of the North- South | | | | constitute the basic norms of the proposed forum. |
| negotiations in the late seventies induced many | | | | Keeping in mind those diverse attitudes, the seven |
| developing countries to explore the possible areas of | | | | South Asian states (Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, |
| South-South co-operation. A number of initiatives on | | | | Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka) formally |
| regional co-operation were launched at that period. | | | | started their co-operation from their first summit held |
| For example, Economic Community of West African | | | | on 8th December 1985 in Dhaka. They were aware |
| States (ECOWAS) in 1975 and Southern African | | | | that heterogeneous issues might hinder their |
| Development Co-ordination Conference (SADCC) in | | | | co-operation, but for attaining their respective |
| 1980 were formed. With the collapse of the dream | | | | objectives they decided to work together. Their |
| of an equitable global economic order, many states | | | | desire for economic emancipation, helped them to |
| turned their attention towards their own region. | | | | start rethinking and reassessing their own resources. |
| Nearly every continent now has some kind of | | | | Although the seven South Asian states started their |
| regional organisation, sometimes more than one. | | | | integration, the prospect of SAARC as an effective |
| SAARC is one of such arrangements. Politically, the | | | | body for regional integration continues to be viewed |
| bilateral atmosphere between India and some of its | | | | with scepticism. When countries in other regions are |
| neighbouring countries deteriorated during 1974-76. As | | | | trying to minimise their differences, it is disconcerting |
| a result, these neighbours started looking for regional | | | | to see that this region (home to half of the world's |
| and international approaches to pressure India so as | | | | poor) remains trapped in conflict and war, sapping its |
| to extract accommodation from it on their respective | | | | energy and resources that could be diverted to |
| bilateral issues. Bangladesh's attempt to raise the | | | | launching an offensive on poverty. In this post-cold |
| river-water sharing issue at the UN in 1976, Nepal's | | | | war period, and at a time when we are at the |
| proposal to get itself recognised as a zone of peace | | | | threshold of a new century, South Asia should not be |
| and Pakistan's active diplomacy at the UN in to get | | | | out of peace, harmony and development even for a |
| South Asia declared as a nuclear-weapon free zone | | | | single day. Analysis of differences among the SAARC |
| may be recalled here. Soviet military intervention in | | | | states and suggesting solution is thus a very |
| Afghanistan in 1979 brought about a serious | | | | important and timely issue. |
| deterioration in the South Asian security situation and | | | | In the present paper focus will be placed on the |
| created an urgency for getting together in the region. | | | | heterogeneity among SAARC states and its effect |
| Although it is true that the external pressures to | | | | on the regional integration process in South Asia. |
| form a South Asian regional organisation were not as | | | | There are of course some strong commonalties |
| great as it was in the case of the European | | | | among the South Asian states, for example, their |
| Community or ASEAN, they were not entirely absent | | | | colonial past, a broadly common attitude towards |
| or insignificant. Internal or external what ever was | | | | Western countries, common needs development, |
| the cause the level of urgency for regional | | | | common needs to alleviate poverty, some similarity in |
| co-operation was not equal among the South Asian | | | | culture, etc. These similarities could be helpful for the |
| states. | | | | states to minimize their differences. And one most |
| In May 1980, Bangladesh had mooted the proposal | | | | positive aspect is that the member states of SAARC |
| for a South Asian regional organisation after sounding | | | | are hopeful about their success. In the paper I will |
| out some small South Asian states. India and | | | | also try to show that, if heterogeneity is greater in |
| Pakistan, the two big powers in South Asia, | | | | South Asia, the regional integration will be less |
| expressed strong reservations. This hesitancy reveals | | | | effective. In case those differences can be |
| the existence of heterogeneity among the South | | | | minimized, greater integration will be possible. |
| Asian states. India was highly suspicious of the | | | | The first chapter will give an overview on the general |
| proposal and viewed it as a new device to | | | | issue of regional integration, including some specific |
| institutionalise the neighbours 'ganging up' against India | | | | reference to SAARC. The second chapter will focus |
| to extract concessions on issues affecting each of | | | | on heterogeneity among the SAARC states. The |
| them individually. Pakistan feared that any South | | | | third chapter will address heterogeneity in the political |
| Asian forum would eventually further India's interests | | | | field and searching for commonality in this area. The |
| and legitimise its regional dominance in South Asia. | | | | fourth chapter will concern heterogeneity and |
| Also, according to Pakistani view, in South Asia | | | | convergence in economic areas. |